Privacy · the television itself

Take the television off the network.

A smart TV is a data-collection device that you do not control and your guest did not choose. The answer is not to trust it. The answer is to disconnect it, and let a box you do control do the work.

Everything below is a documented, public case. Every claim links to its source.

What has already happened

Not predictions. Four cases, each one investigated by a regulator or published in a peer-reviewed venue.

LG · 2013
It kept sending after the setting was switched off
A UK owner found that "collection of watching info" was on by default, and that after he switched it off the television still transmitted every channel change — along with the names of files on a USB stick he had plugged in. The Information Commissioner's Office opened an inquiry. LG's position was that this was viewing information, not personal data.
ICO inquiry →
Samsung · 2015
The microphone one — written in their own policy
Samsung's own privacy policy warned: "if your spoken words include personal or other sensitive information, that information will be among the data captured and transmitted to a third party through your use of Voice Recognition". After the coverage, Samsung revised the wording on 10 February 2015 to name the transcription company, Nuance.
NPR, Feb 2015 →
Vizio · 2017
Second by second, on 11 million televisions
The US Federal Trade Commission and the New Jersey Attorney General settled with Vizio for $2.2 million. Regulators said the televisions captured second-by-second information about what was on screen, by default, and that IP addresses were passed to data aggregators who attached household details. Vizio was ordered to delete the data and to ask for express consent from then on.
FTC case file →
Research · 2024
It runs even when the TV is only a screen
Researchers from UC Davis, University College London and UC3M measured the network traffic leaving Samsung and LG televisions. Automatic content recognition kept identifying what was on screen even when the set was used as an external monitor — that is, fed over HDMI by another device. Presented at the ACM Internet Measurement Conference 2024.
UCL summary →

Why "just turn the setting off" is not an answer

The setting was off, and it still sent
That is the whole point of the 2013 LG case. You cannot verify a promise you have no way to check, on a device whose software updates itself.
"I only use it as a screen" does not help either
The 2024 measurements found content recognition still running while the picture came in over HDMI from something else. Putting a box in front of the TV does not switch the TV off.
There is one thing a television cannot do
Send anything with no network. That is the only guarantee on this page that does not depend on anybody's word.

Three steps

  1. 1
    Never put the television on Wi-Fi
    Skip the network step in its setup. If it is already connected, forget the network and remove any account from it.
  2. 2
    Put the Hotel TV box on an HDMI input
    The box carries the network, the apps and the guest's channels. The television becomes a panel that shows a picture.
  3. 3
    Switch the remote's microphone off
    TV Box Tools does it in one step. Two reasons: a voice command is a door into Android's settings, and nobody should have to wonder what a microphone in their room is doing.
What you give up
The television's own apps and its own casting. The box replaces both, so in practice you lose the parts you were not using anyway — but it is a trade, not magic, and you should know it before you decide.

What Hotel TV does, and what it does not

It does
No content recognition. No microphone. No personal data collected from the guest. Their sign-ins erased before the next arrival, with the promise written on the screen they signed into.
It does not
It does not control the apps you install on it. Netflix, YouTube and the rest have their own privacy policies and their own trackers. We will not pretend otherwise — we are not in a position to promise anything about them.

Our own policy is here: Privacy policy

If you run a BnB, this is also your liability

A hotel has a legal department. A host with two apartments does not. You are the one responsible for what happens in that room, and a television that reports what your guest watches is a thing you put there.

A television off the network is one less thing to answer for — and one more line you can put in your listing.

Questions

Should I connect the television to Wi-Fi?
No. The box does all the work. A television with no network cannot send anywhere what your guest is watching, and that is a guarantee no privacy setting can give you.
Why does the microphone on the remote not work?
We switch it off on purpose, for two reasons. First, a voice command opens Android's settings or the Play Store, and from there a guest can change whatever they like. Second, privacy: in 2015 Samsung's own privacy policy warned that words spoken in front of the television might be sent to a third party for transcription. In a guest room, nobody wants that.
My television is new. Is it still doing this?
We cannot tell you about your model, and we will not guess. What we can tell you is that the 2024 measurements were made on televisions on sale at the time, and that content recognition kept running even over HDMI. If you want certainty rather than a probability, the network cable is the only lever you control.
Does Hotel TV collect anything about my guests?
No personal data, no content recognition, no microphone. The apps you install on top of it have their own policies, which we neither control nor speak for.